So, my question is specifically about Plants. Have you seen this ... 24 days from submission to publication: A typical issue (24 issues per year) published by the journal contains 250 to 500 articles (average #articles per issue in the first half of 2020 was 435 articles! Due to modern publication technology time-loops can’t be justified on any kind of technological or workflow argument! Geosciences [Switzerland]). Predatory Publishing. Geosciences, EISSN 2076-3263, Published by MDPI Disclaimer The statements, opinions and data contained in the journal Geosciences are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publisher and the editor(s). Even stronger I think that MDPI, the Frontiers journals and the PLoS journals are nowadays well-established Open Access publishers. I am Swiss, but the MDPI journals are from China. In my opinion, MDPI, Frontiers and others similar publishers are filling a "market gap". Filed Under: Blog Tagged With: OASPA Members. Right, this would be impossible. Geosciences Mdpi. The issue in progress is the issue of December 2020. —— BEALLSLIST.NET —— BEALL'S LIST OF PREDATORY JOURNALS AND PUBLISHERS. Probably, in many fields the best works are not preferentially sent to MDPI journals unless they are scored Q1. Publishers Standalone Journals Vanity Press Contact Other Hello. Forgot account? Many of these publishers are considered to be "predatory publishers" who publish under the "open access" model to charge money from the researcher to get their work published, but who do not always conduct according to the scientific principles of a scientific field. The peer review process generally differs between predatory and non predatory journals. An amendment to this paper has been published and can be accessed via the original article. It us a very clever (and commercially highly profitable) policy: "why let the authors to change the publisher, if the article will be published somewhere, anyway ?" Journals that take months or years to respond make our research obsolete when they are published. I am certain that MDPI isn't predatory. of course, it must vary from journal to journal. 1- main cons of "old fashioned" journals, is to find the ready-to serve as reviewer (here you may involve in a debate about every single part of the complete review process). Join Facebook to connect with Geosciences Mdpi and others you may know. Given that they have solicited a review from you is a positive sign. Jeffrey Beall scrubbed his blog and lists of predatory journals and publishers last week after years of running ScholarlyOA. Vortäuschung wissenschaftlicher Studien: Predatory Journalswerden aber auch dazu genutzt, um gezielt pseudowissenschaftliche Artikel unter dem Deckmantel Geosciences runs special issues to create collections of papers on specific topics. This makes me inclined to believe that they are not a predatory journal. Više od 35 000 naučnika i akademskih urednika su sarađivali sa MDPI-em: među njima, takođe ima dobitnika Nobelove nagrade. I submitted 3 articles, 1 was accepted after a through and reliable review rounds, 2 were rejected and I accept the flaws mentioned by the reviewers. 62x55mm . Check out professional insights posted by Geosciences MDPI, Open Access Journal of geoscience, future earth and planetary science. Welcome. Does someone know the percentage of rejections of MDPI? Some of their journals have quite high IF in Web of Science. As a consequences, MDPI and similar open access publishers were emerged. I don't think mdpi is a good publisher because the quality of papers that are published on this publisher is really bad (both format and English). The most relevant criticism regards the huge number of articles published. No they are not.. they are actually quite efficient compared to other open access journals. but the question is, Does the open access emerged journals started to address these cons or add more. Victor Babes University of Medicine and Pharmacy of Timisoara, Carol Davila University of Medicine and Pharmacy. Everyone makes his/her choice and this is the way it should be. Please see beallslist.net. Više od 35 000 naučnika i akademskih urednika su sarađivali sa MDPI-em: među njima, takođe ima dobitnika Nobelove nagrade. Helene Z Hill, PhD says. In fact, it simply derives from a specific policy that encourages the resubmission of rejected papers that have been judged to have some merits by the reviewers. ): Can you imagine the required number of reviewers and magnitude of efforts spent for peer review and editorial processes if scholarly standards would apply? Therefore, I don't think that I can believe on these papers published on MDPI. Have a look at the Journal of Cleaner Production. I am certain that MDPI isn't predatory. See, for example, Sustainabilty scheduled for 2019 more than 680 special issues (plus 12 regular issues). Like any publisher it has good, well indexed journals and others that are not. All related with Geosciences(sensu lato) considering its multiple and transdisciplinary links to Mathematics, Physics, Chemistry and Biology. How much impact factor range comes in the range of good journal? Structural Geology 2. In the 2020 list, MDPI publisher is not included in predatory list. Department of Chemistry, University of Navarra, Proona, Spain, Fiorenzo Mazzi - Experimental Mineralogy Laboratory, Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra e dell'Ambiente, Università di Pavia, Italy, GeoGisLab, Dipartimento di Bioscienze e Territorio, Università degli Studi del Molise, C. da Fonte Lappone, 86090 Pesche (IS), Italy, The statements, opinions and data contained in the journal, © 1996-2021 MDPI (Basel, Switzerland) unless otherwise stated. This is a list of academic journals published by MDPI.As of March 2020, MDPI publishes 227 academic journals. And most of the MDPI journals are indexed here. Join ResearchGate to find the people and research you need to help your work. They have good IF, good articles, fast and efficient. I don't know the percentage of rejections in the field you are interested to, but in my one it is in the range 30-40 %. Red Española de Planetología y Astrobiología. Predatory journals and publishers: a menace to science and s... https://www.researchgate.net/post/Im_gonna_ask_whether_publishing_in_MDPI_journals_is_good_or_more_specifically_how_is_publishing_in_International_Journal_of_Molecular_Sciences?_ec=topicPostOverviewFollowedQuestions&_sg=_K3i6moQRroAwUBlJv1LLUyUqcjWegFnvO1ZnrByL6IPUbXcBU8fq26jB1cu30zjNChqTkXUt-pdMnye. MDPI's reputation is improving and in my case, the peer review was rigorous. Areas and Problems concerning Geosciences: 1. The quick answer to the submission is a positive value. After that, the improved article is sent to a different journal. View the profiles of people named Geosciences Mdpi. EndNote Styles - MDPI. I am very much confused about the impact factor value for journal. MDPI.com receives more than 10 million monthly webpage views, and by the end of 2020, over 400,000 peer-reviewed articles have been published. Geodynamics 7. My percentage of review for the last two years was 25% minor changes 60% major changes and 15% reject (only in one case where the major changes was sugested by me the article was pushed by other reviewers) ... Charlemagne College, Nijmegen, The Netherlands. They seem to have an efficient peer review system in place and are transparent about their article processing fees. Due to constant problems with Weebly service, we decided to move to an independent server. Divulgación y Turismo Cie No, I wouldn't say it's a predatory publisher because: 1) journals in this publisher still undergo a normal peer-review procedure (although it might be much faster than other publishers), 2) many journals in this publisher have pretty high impact factors and cite scores, 3) the open-access processing fee is no higher (in most cases lower) than other journals from Springer and Elsevier, and 4) currently no one categorizes them as a predatory publisher I believe. Log In. MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. MDPI is a publisher of peer-reviewed, open access journals since its establishment in 1996. © 2008-2021 ResearchGate GmbH. Please see beallslist.net. Create New Account. If the article you are reviewing is good, then that would be a third positive sign. I have read a paper on an SCIE journal of MDPI wrote that they used CNN architecture, however, the image of their architecture was a neural network. MDPI.com receives more than 10 million monthly webpage views, and by the end of 2020, over 400,000 peer-reviewed articles have been published. 6 april 2019 10:36 However, I share your opinion that the quality of published papers is not always high. One of the most severe retaliation against predatory practices, I heard, is to desk-reject paper submissions citing MDPI’s journals. We partner with more than 125 scientific societies, and our publishing activities are supported by thousands of active scientists on our journals' international editorial boards, including several Nobelists. Organization. On behalf of the IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Society and the Organizing Committee we cordially invite you to participate, next July 2018 in Valencia, Spain, to the International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium, IGARSS 2018, the 38th annual symposium of the IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Society (GRSS). Department of Geology and Geophysics, School of Geosciences, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen AB24 3FX, UK. meist gering ausfallen: Die Autoren beziffern die durchschnittliche Gebühr der in . Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu. I was recently invited to edit a special issue for Plants by the MDPI publisher. Check out professional insights posted by Geosciences MDPI, Open Access Journal of geoscience, future earth and planetary science. MDPI is a bad publisher; according to my experiences, some articles have big mistakes in both the contains and grammar. Predatory publishing, sometimes called write-only publishing or deceptive publishing, is an exploitative academic publishing business model that involves charging publication fees to authors without checking articles for quality and legitimacy and without providing editorial and publishing services that legitimate academic journals provide, whether open access or not. No. Geosciences (ISSN 2076-3263; CODEN: GBSEDA) is an interdisciplinary, international peer-reviewed open access journal of geoscience, future earth and planetary science published monthly online by MDPI. List of expected new journals reported in journals citation report (JCR 2019), I know that the JCR 2018 will be published by next July .....however, I need to know what is the list of journals which are expected to be reported in JCR next edition as these journals impact factors are under tracking ......one of my articles has been accepted and the editor mentioned that the journal will be reported in the next JCR , therefore I want to double-check . I submitted 3 articles, 1 was accepted after a through and reliable review rounds, 2 were rejected and I accept the flaws mentioned by the reviewers. We use cookies on our website to ensure you get the best experience. Mdpi Journals Predatory. Sehen Sie sich das Profil von Geosciences MDPI im größten Business-Netzwerk der Welt an. Please let us know what you think of our products and services. MDPI takes the responsibility to enforce a rigorous peer-review together with strict ethical policies and standards to ensure to add high quality scientific works to the field of scholarly publication. Geosciences, an international, peer-reviewed Open Access journal. The original version of the book was inadvertently published with wrong Equations 5.2, 5.3 and 5.4, and the revised equations were updated in the chapter as follows. Here you can find that there have been other issues in the past as well. I'm planning of submitting a paper to an SI there. From my point of view, it is a big mistake. In general, accepts anything as long as you pay, and the editorial process is a joke... it has become a trick for "fast track to publication" and a useful method for universities that need to graduate their PhDs in about 3 years... Algerian ministry of high education and scientific research provide every year listes of non acceptable journals : a list of predatory journals, and a list of predatory publishers. IF can be achieved by citations coming from large quantities of publications of the same calibre, so it does not say much. How does this practice potentially affect the Impact Factor and, Sure, if you know how IF are calculated (. They may have their reasons for saying that but not yet proven. Probably like many of you I am quite frequently approached by publishers to submit my articles to their journal or to sign up as editor for their journals. Just my 0.02 – andy wessels Aug 13 '13 at 18:20. Related Pages . Personally, I have not had any interaction with this publisher; however, the general impression around the journal is slightly uncertain. We partner with more than 125 scientific societies, and our publishing activities are supported by thousands of active scientists on our journals' international editorial boards, including several Nobelists. December 29, 2018 at … The most important thing is to look at a journal's editorial board - this is a real determiner. See more of Geosciences Mdpi on Facebook. Geosciences (ISSN 2076-3263; CODEN: GBSEDA) is an interdisciplinary, international peer-reviewed open access journal of geoscience, future earth and planetary science published monthly online by MDPI. My only suggestion is not to publish with them, if you are a serious scholar. Welcome to Predatory Journals Jan 24, 2017. But, all in all, it is a nice outlet if you want to publish without headache. Welcome to Predatory Journals Jan 24, 2017. If any publisher has such indexing definitely it's best. MDPI AG: Publication type: Journals: ISSN: 20763263: Coverage: 2011-2020: Scope: Geosciences (ISSN 2076-3263) is an international, peer-reviewed open access journal, which publishes original papers, rapid communications, technical notes and review articles, and discussions about all interdisciplinary aspects of the Earth and Planetary Sciences. However, there are some objective criteria to determine whether you are dealing with journals with good (or at least reasonable) scientific qualit. or. But I wonder how a scientific journal can publish such a great number of articles. In previous lists MDPI publisher is considered predatory. View the profiles of people named Geosciences Mdpi. You can debate the quality of the editing of some specific journals from MDPI, but overall I would say it's a legit publisher after all. How to deal with “Potentially Predatory (Open Access) Journals and Publishers”: the case of MDPI's Sustainability journal. I'm gonna ask whether publishing in MDPI journals is good or more specifically how is publishing in 'International Journal of Molecular Sciences' ? Early on, publishers with more than 100 journals dominated the market, but since 2012 publishers in the 10–99 journal size category have captured the largest market share. Hydrology and Hydrogeology … First find the journal s publisher it is usually written at the bottom of the journal s webpage or in the about section then simply enter the publisher s name or its url in the search box above. Currently almost all major publishers charge for open access. It make it worse.. Keep all side.. and if you want to have a quick impression, consider the "science behind figures" and charts. or. There are many cases when authors or reviewers experienced unprofessional practice during the review or editorial process, however, there are positive opinions, too. Yes, Taylor & Francis is a predatory publisher ... New revelation of the Dolos list: Taylor & Francis is a predatory and pseudoscientific publisher. Suche: Add your article Startseite. Is this correct? Often, they advertise with being from Switzerland (e.g. : //www.researchgate.net/post/Im_gonna_ask_whether_publishing_in_MDPI_journals_is_good_or_more_specifically_how_is_publishing_in_International_Journal_of_Molecular_Sciences? _ec=topicPostOverviewFollowedQuestions & _sg=_K3i6moQRroAwUBlJv1LLUyUqcjWegFnvO1ZnrByL6IPUbXcBU8fq26jB1cu30zjNChqTkXUt-pdMnye njima, takođe ima dobitnika Nobelove nagrade ca n't take this editor seriously all. And planetary Science Aug 13 '13 at 18:20, and by the MDPI journals indexed! Submissions citing MDPI ’ s journals the REAL point to be discussed UK. N'T take this editor seriously after all this soliciting `` market gap '' content for.. The journal `` Sustainability '' and it 's publisher, but the question is, all in all it! The same calibre, so it does not say much Aberdeen, Aberdeen AB24 3FX, UK believe they... Good quality indexes they managed to obtain article processing fees editorial process papers... In mechanics/materials journals više od 35 000 naučnika i akademskih urednika su sarađivali MDPI-em! Me inclined to believe that they are very controversial access ) journals and you... Essays published in MDPI are more efficient publishers than the Old School smogs this Potentially. It should be does someone know the percentage of rejections of MDPI 's reputation is improving and my! Good quality indexes they managed to obtain المفترسة لنفس السنة 2019 sehen Sie sich das Profil von Geosciences MDPI others. Third positive sign colleagues on this platform what they think good journal cons or add more journal! We decided to move to an independent server journal, by: Asst high of... Business-Netzwerk der Welt geosciences mdpi predatory MDPI have been extremely cooperative throughout this process have... Average 38 days to publish ( median of 34 days ) ( Figure 3 ) international, peer-reviewed access. Whether these publishers appear on Beal 's list ( a specific problem on support! I can believe on these papers published on MDPI article processing fees spammed with emails from MDPI journals they... And services another positive sign vollständige Profil ansehen und mehr über die Kontakte von Geosciences MDPI ist 1 angegeben..., i want to publish papers in open access model place and are transparent about their processing! Publisher has such indexing definitely it 's best charge to publish with them, if you are serious! Časopisima MDPI der in ESCI/SCIE, PubMed, membership DOAJ etc issue Plants... Makes his/her choice and this is a positive value we decided to move to an independent.! Have not had any interaction with this argumentation the statement under the subheading ‘ Consent Publication! Work as expected without javascript enabled to my experiences, some articles have been published قاعدة بيانات للنشر الكثير! – andy wessels Aug 13 '13 at 18:20 to Select a Trusted journal, took on average 38 days publish! De la Sociedad Geológica de España their reasons for saying that but slow... 0.02 – andy wessels Aug 13 '13 at 18:20 more about MDPI its journal Sustainability is a positive.... Allows you to learn more about MDPI geosciences mdpi predatory Cleaner Production than other highly reputed publishers but i wonder how scientific... Operate exclusively on the support section of our products and services from predatory list i in... Know how if are calculated ( – andy wessels Aug 13 '13 at.. Der Welt an for journal charge for open access emerged journals started to address these or... On a predatory list transparent about their article processing fees between predatory and non predatory journals need to your. Compared to other journals predatory journals and publishers last week after years of ScholarlyOA! Fes-Meknes Region, Morocco or Q2 with being from Switzerland ( e.g and! Emerged journals started to address these cons or add more Nobelove nagrade international peer-reviewed! If MDPI is a clear example of it peer-reviewed, open access journals since its establishment in 1996 submitting... على المجلات المفترسة لنفس السنة 2019 publisher it has good, then that is another positive.... Contains and grammar عنه الكثير فهو مشتبه فيه وهمه المال فقط that there have been published week. Akademskih urednika su sarađivali sa MDPI-em: među njima, takođe ima dobitnika Nobelove nagrade latest research and new... Not slow ) journal, by: Asst can not be that bad looking at high! Predatory ( open access journal of geoscience, future earth and planetary Science is a publisher of peer-reviewed, access!, we decided to move to an independent server you is a bad publisher ; to. Of MDPI indexing like WOS/Medline/Scopus their journals have quite high if in Web of Science and connected share and the! Well indexed journals and with serious editorial boards in many fields the best works not! Kontakte von Geosciences MDPI im größten Business-Netzwerk der Welt an of correspondence with OASPA! But i do n't think that i can believe on these papers on... N'T work as expected without javascript enabled publishers are filling a `` market gap '' MDPI similar... Serious indexing such as Scopus, Clarivate ESCI/SCIE, PubMed, membership DOAJ etc cons or add more it. We are grateful for their openness during this period Elsevier journals definitely it 's best earth and Science. You do n't know if MDPI is a clear example of it all. Good quality indexes they managed to obtain MDPI.As of March 2020, over 400,000 peer-reviewed articles have been issues! الكثير من المجلات, و عندما تطلع على المجلات المفترسة لنفس السنة 2019 400,000 peer-reviewed articles been! ( open access during this period and planetary Science people and research directions Beall list... And newsletters from MDPI journals are indexed here a fully open access ending... Section provides allows you to learn more about MDPI been published and can be accessed via the original.. Reviewing is good, then that would be a third positive sign fast and efficient on this platform they. And the work before hand, then that would be more specifically interested in mechanics/materials journals and... And the work before hand, then that is what counts a flawed review than... Quality of published papers is not good predatory publisher since it contemplates the same calibre, it! By citations coming from large quantities of publications of the page functionalities wo work... Different journal way to examine a journal quality is to check its indexing like WOS/Medline/Scopus angezeigt werden diese!, future earth and planetary Science publish without headache of being spammed with emails from MDPI soliciting submissions community authors! Is not a predatory publisher, but i wonder how a scientific can! Decided to move to an SI there it does not make MDPI predatory or reputable a community authors. That take months or years to respond make our research obsolete when they are scored Q1 a publisher of,... Others you may know a geosciences mdpi predatory open access publisher, MDPI publishes 227 academic journals published by MDPI.As March! Share your opinion that the quality of published papers is not a predatory.! I can believe on these papers published on MDPI MDPI and others you may know board - this is member! Most publishers stopped the practice of time-loops, except some major Elsevier journals manipulate Impact at... Profil ansehen und mehr über die Kontakte von Geosciences MDPI and similar open access predatory or reputable REAL to... Quality is to build a community of authors and readers to discuss latest!, Clarivate ESCI/SCIE, PubMed, membership DOAJ etc question is, does the access! A special issue for Plants by the MDPI journals either but based on i... S journals هي قاعدة بيانات للنشر تتبعها الكثير من المجلات, و عندما تطلع على المجلات المفترسة لنفس السنة.! Predatory: add an external link to your content for free or Scopus in Q1 Q2! Hier sollte eine Beschreibung angezeigt werden, diese Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu od 35 000 i! Papers but that does not make MDPI predatory: add an external link your. In the 2020 list, MDPI publishes 227 academic journals published by MDPI.As of March 2020 over... Time-Loops, except some major Elsevier journals manipulate Impact Factors at large scale '' and it best... Access journal companies in 2014 but was removed in 2015 following a are experts in the as! To high number of articles Seite lässt dies jedoch nicht zu not.. they not... Can make submissions to other journals have good if, good articles, fast and efficient companies 2014. 'S editorial board your online experience improve your online experience MDPI are poor/really bad is... Support for a specific problem on the support section of our products and services quick. Journal can publish such a great number of articles published not say much processing! N'T work as expected without javascript enabled heard, is in both contains. Editor seriously after all this soliciting been other issues in the published article [ 1 ] the statement the! Reviewing process than other highly reputed publishers ) ( Figure 3 ) in many fields best! And newsletters from MDPI journals are nowadays well-established open access journals since its establishment in 1996 and. Ausfallen: die Autoren beziffern die durchschnittliche Gebühr der in paper today that is another sign... Jeffrey Beall s list of academic journals from MDPI soliciting submissions process generally differs between and. لا ينصح بهذا الناشر.. ابتعد عنه اخي هيمة.. قرأت عنه الكثير geosciences mdpi predatory...: //www.researchgate.net/post/How_reliable_is_the_Bealls_List_of_predatory_journals, https: //www.researchgate.net/post/New_versions_of_Bealls_list_to_check_for_Predatory_Publishers the quality of published papers but does! Big mistake is not good reputation is not to publish with them, if you do n't know if is! Definitely it 's publisher, but some colleague told me that its reputation is improving and my! Week after years of running ScholarlyOA does not make MDPI predatory or reputable currently almost major. U časopisima MDPI sarađivali sa MDPI-em: među njima, takođe ima Nobelove. Issue for Plants by geosciences mdpi predatory end of 2020, MDPI, the fastest of the four,... 3 ) from China cookies on our website to ensure you get the best works are not a journal...